Rep. Jimmie T. Smith: “Stand your ground is core to the American way of life.”


Photo courtesy of Jimmie T. Smith

Last week, the Dream Defenders and a number of Floridians against the state’s self-defense law commonly known as “stand your ground” fled to Tallahassee to fight for repealing SYG or at least changing it.

A House Subcommittee on Criminal Justice voted against repealing or changing the law all together, opting instead to expand the scope of it.

Once the hearing was over, Florida Representative Jimmie T. Smith talked about why the law was so important and why it’s still needed.

“Stand your ground is core to the American way of life.”

For Smith, and those who believe in SYG, his comments encapsulate an antiquated political way of thinking.

What exactly is the American way of life and where is the core? Let’s try this on as an example.

On November 1st, many Floridians who rely on food stamps were impacted by a cut to the program aimed at reigning in America’s spiraling debt. The cut will impact over one million children and about 700,000 elderly and disabled.

To combat an economic problem in America, many politicians in Washington D.C., Democrats and Republicans, decided to cut a food program that serves the poor, the elderly, and America’s children. Doesn’t that sound backwards?

So for many who are against SYG and saw the case of George Zimmerman as one reason why the law needs adjusting, hearing Smith make such a statement may sound callous.

Since 2005, justifiable homicides are up by 200 percent in Florida and due to the convoluted language included in SYG, the Sanford police department decided against arresting Zimmerman and it altered the jury instructions when Zimmerman went to trial.

Coupling the two, doubling down on cuts to social programs to reign in debt when America’s economy is still bad for many, and expanding, at least on the surface, a law that has aided in the increase of justifiable homicides seems backwards.

Is that what Smith means when he references America’s core? A law that only furthers America’s gun culture or the idea that Americans have the right to self-defense?

At time of publish, Rep. Smith had not responded to my request for clarification on his statements.

For me, his comments seem outdated; almost a representation of why the Republican Party is dying a slow and painful death. It’s a failure to embrace change or progress, just like those who believe that cutting food stamps for the poor punishes those who abuse the system or will save America’s dying economy.

Is this the core that we are protecting?


Check out the latest Jason Henry Project for news and commentary on Florida and national politics, international affairs, sports, and more!

Follow Jason on Twitter @JHenryProject!

Follow The Jason Henry Project on Facebook!


2 thoughts on “Rep. Jimmie T. Smith: “Stand your ground is core to the American way of life.”

  1. “Is that what Smith means when he references America’s core? A law that only furthers America’s gun culture or the idea that Americans have the right to self-defense?”

    All human beings have an inherent right to self defense. Fortunately americans also have a 2nd Amendment. There is a lot more common sense in America’s “gun culture” than the mindlessly repeated talking points in your post.


  2. Stand your ground is core. There are statistics all over the internet, that show what ever the writer wants them to show. That being said, it is historical, the idea to stand your ground.
    Food stamps are core to nothing, and those cuts, are the result of a short term boost ending that was designed to help “boost” the economy. Do not misunderstand me, helping people is core to the American way, or at least it is to me, but food stamps do not help people.
    Concerning the Zimmerman trial, did you even bother looking at the jury line up he was pitted against. Six women found him not guilty. If I recall most of them were mothers as well.
    Maybe justifiable homicides are up 200 percent because more bad guys are being killed instead of good guys.
    You may find next year that the republican party is not nearly as dead as people say it is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s